Publico la respuesta que di en la web de Richard Dawkins que preguntaba "¿Cómo denunciamos la violencia musulmana sin denunciar descaradamente a los musulmanes?"
***
No one is condemning
Muslim people for crimes they did not commit. The belonging to a group
does not imply responsibility, not at least any judicial responsibility,
for the crimes committed by other member of the group.
Germans were not responsible for the crimes committed for Nazis, not
even in the case of considering themselves Nazis (if no actual
implication on particular crimes). These judicial principia applies also
to actual case of Islamic violence. But they, innocent Germans of III
Reich and innocent Muslims of nowadays, must face the fact that violence
emerged from the same respective roots. The root of National Socialism
is arguably “Mein Kampf”, and the one for Islam is undeniably the Koran.
Of course I am not establishing a moral equivalence with both
doctrines. Koran and Mein Kampf are not the same; the first one is a
religion capable of doing good, much more than Mein Kampf which is a
political legacy to destroy democracy. But the fact is that both have
been used for violence in large number, and we should be able to
determine where exactly those bad ideas come from. We should be able to
reform it and, if necessary, to refund the religion in order to get a
pure doctrine that get rid of evil seeds.
